Tragic Multi-Vehicle Accident on Interstate 77 Claims the Lives of Nicholas R. Oleski and Justine Hitchcock of Cleveland, Ohio; Virginia State Police Investigate the Fatal Crash Involving Four Vehicles
A devastating multi-vehicle crash on Interstate 77 North near mile marker 9 in Carroll County, Virginia, claimed the lives of Nicholas R. Oleski and Justine A. Hitchcock, both 34 and residents of Cleveland, Ohio. The accident, which occurred in the early hours of Tuesday, November 19, 2024, around 2:55 a.m., involved a 2025 Mercedes-Benz CLA250, a 2019 Ford F250, a 2023 Volvo VRN tractor-trailer, and a 2025 Peterbilt tractor-trailer. The collision has left their families, friends, and colleagues grieving an unimaginable loss while authorities continue to investigate the circumstances surrounding the tragedy.
Timeline of the Incident
According to the Virginia State Police, the sequence of events began when Nicholas Oleski, driving a 2025 Mercedes-Benz CLA250 northbound on Interstate 77, lost control of his vehicle. The car veered off the left side of the road, striking the end of a railing. This initial collision caused the Mercedes to spin back onto the interstate, where it collided with a 2019 Ford F250. The impact pushed the vehicle into the path of two large trucks: a 2023 Volvo VRN tractor-trailer and a 2025 Peterbilt tractor-trailer.
The Mercedes came to rest on the right side of the interstate, heavily damaged. Emergency services quickly arrived at the scene to assess the situation. Tragically, Justine Hitchcock, the passenger, was pronounced dead at the scene. Despite being rushed to the hospital, Nicholas Oleski succumbed to his injuries a short time later. Both individuals had been wearing seatbelts at the time of the crash, underscoring the severity of the impact.
No Injuries to Other Drivers
The drivers of the Ford F250, the Volvo tractor-trailer, and the Peterbilt tractor-trailer were unharmed. Police confirmed that no passengers were in those vehicles. However, the collision caused significant disruption, with debris scattered across multiple lanes and traffic halted for hours as investigators worked to reconstruct the scene and clear the wreckage.
Tributes to Nicholas R. Oleski
Nicholas Oleski, affectionately known as “Nick” to those who knew him, was a prominent attorney at the Cleveland-based law firm McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman Co., LPA. His colleagues and friends were deeply saddened by the news of his sudden passing. In a heartfelt statement, the firm expressed their condolences:
“It is with great sadness that we share the news of the passing of our esteemed colleague and partner, Nicholas (Nick) Oleski. Nick was a great lawyer, a valued colleague, and a treasured friend. McCarthy Lebit extends our deepest condolences to Nick’s family and loved ones. He will be missed by all and remembered always.”
Nick was highly regarded for his legal acumen and dedication to his clients. A graduate of Case Western Reserve University School of Law, he specialized in corporate and business law, earning respect throughout Ohio’s legal community. Beyond his professional achievements, Nick was known for his warmth, integrity, and passion for helping others. Friends describe him as a compassionate and charismatic individual who brought a positive energy to every room he entered.
Remembering Justine A. Hitchcock
Justine Hitchcock, also 34, was a beloved figure in her community. While her obituary and funeral arrangements are pending release by her family, those close to her describe her as a kind, vibrant, and caring individual. A Cleveland native, she was passionate about her work and cherished her connections with family and friends. Justine’s sudden and tragic death has left an irreplaceable void in the lives of those who knew her.
Impact on the Cleveland Community
The loss of Nicholas and Justine has sent shockwaves through Cleveland, where both were deeply rooted. Friends and colleagues have taken to social media to share their memories and condolences. “Nick was a beacon of professionalism and kindness,” one friend wrote. “He always went the extra mile to support others, both in his career and personal life.”
Another close friend of Justine shared, “She was one of the most genuine people I’ve ever met. Her laughter and warmth could light up any room. This is an unimaginable loss.”
Investigation Underway
The Virginia State Police continue to investigate the cause of the crash. Authorities are examining factors such as weather conditions, road design, and potential driver errors to understand what led to the tragic sequence of events. Initial reports indicate that both Nicholas and Justine were wearing seatbelts, and no alcohol or drugs are suspected to have played a role. However, the investigation remains ongoing.
The stretch of Interstate 77 where the crash occurred is known for its challenging curves and variable weather conditions, particularly in the early morning hours when visibility can be limited. Virginia State Police have urged drivers to exercise caution and stay alert, especially in areas prone to accidents.
Outpouring of Support
In the wake of the tragedy, the Cleveland and Carroll County communities have come together to support the families of Nicholas and Justine. Vigils and memorials have been organized to honor their lives, providing a space for loved ones to grieve and remember the positive impact both individuals made.
The law firm McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman has announced plans to establish a scholarship fund in Nicholas’s name, aimed at supporting aspiring law students from Ohio. Similarly, friends of Justine have launched a fundraiser to assist her family with funeral expenses and create a legacy project in her memory.
A Legacy of Kindness and Excellence
The untimely deaths of Nicholas R. Oleski and Justine Hitchcock serve as a poignant reminder of life’s fragility. Both individuals left an indelible mark on those who knew them, not only through their professional accomplishments but also through their kindness, generosity, and zest for life.
As the investigation into the accident continues, their families have requested privacy during this challenging time. Plans for memorial services and tributes will be shared as they become available.
Closing Thoughts
Nicholas and Justine will be remembered as remarkable individuals who touched countless lives. Their sudden loss is a tragedy that underscores the importance of cherishing every moment with loved ones. Though their time was cut short, their legacies will live on in the memories of those who were fortunate to know them.
Rest in peace, Nicholas and Justine.
